Log in

Entries Friends Calendar User Info Previous Previous Next Next
Review: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets - Antarctic Blue
Review: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
Rowling, J. K. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. 1999.

I've been told by dreol, Harry Potter nut and English major that he is, that Chamber of Secrets is the weakest of the seven novels in the series. It certainly seems to be his least favorite; he says he thinks it's because it's less connected with the overarching story and the rest of the novels than the others.

He may be right, but it was still a fun read. And Chamber of Secrets isn't unconnected - not in the least. There was at least one gun on the mantle that comes out in book six (or I assume so; I made the connection with the movie - I haven't yet read book six). If there's one thing Ms. Rowling can do right, I would have to say it's setting everything up... even this early, even in the second book that can get mired in a pile of seven (which by all rights should be less important than the first for VAST FORESHADOWING), I found myself spotting... well, not quite hints and clues, but things - items, people - that would come into play much, much later. And I haven't even read the rest of the series; this is just from my incomplete movie knowledge. So there's something there. Book 2 might not be as connected, but it doesn't lack connection.

Past that, Harry Potter continues to be escapist fiction of the best sort. Rowling does a decent job re-explaining Hogwarts and some of the events and revelations that took place in the first novel - I'm assuming she doesn't continue to do this, once she realizes how rabid her fanbase is and how much they tend to remember, but she does manage quite well. Harry has a personality but not too much of one; his two friends fulfill their roles as sidekick and brain very well. And seriously, I don't mean any of those things in a bad way, as I like Harry, Ron, and Hermoine. But it's good for escapist fiction - you have to be able to substitute yourself for them, in those roles. If I were in junior high school, I'd be gobbling Harry Potter up just for that. Snape's still my favorite character, but huge surprise there. And I'd more or less forgotten about the second movie (more proof that it's not as connected, perhaps?), so part of the Big Twist at the end came as a surprise.

Oh, and I went on a hilarious at one point, which I'll put down as a spoiler: When Ginny comes to Harry to tell him that she thinks she's the one who's been causing all of the trouble with the basilisk, I thought she was Dobby. She was described as acting very much like Dobby, with the rocking at the edge of her seat and her mouth being open - she screamed and ran like Dobby when Percy came by and asked for her spot.

For that matter, I thought Harry'd come to the same conclusion, since Rowling was having him draw the parallel between Ginny and Dobby. And it would have explained Harry's room getting trashed later, because it's already been proven that Dobby would do that (plus, if he's being all Ginny, then he could get in). Nuts for shapechanging house elves. Oh well, in my alternate Harry Potter universe, I guess. ;P

Rowling does goof in a few places - careless mistakes, like confusing "ancestor" with "descendant" at one point and making a dialectical botch in Lucius' Malfoy's speech at another. But these are minor things that are easy to skip over, and overall, I've found the novel enjoyable, quick, and fun.

Next: Julie & Julia: My Year of Cooking Dangerously, by Julie Powell

Tags: ,

10 penguins saved | Harpoon a whale
demota From: demota Date: August 3rd, 2009 10:19 pm (UTC) (Link)
What's this gun on the mantle in book 2?
aquahaute From: aquahaute Date: August 3rd, 2009 11:54 pm (UTC) (Link)
The diary.
demota From: demota Date: August 4th, 2009 02:24 am (UTC) (Link)

It's been a long long time since I've read any of the books.
dreol From: dreol Date: August 5th, 2009 01:21 am (UTC) (Link)
The diary is a huge gun on the mantle, yes. Although, I think she was referring to the necklace specifically. Which is another one.
demota From: demota Date: August 5th, 2009 05:12 am (UTC) (Link)
I'm still confused.

It's been a long time since I"ve erad the books.

What necklace is this?
aquahaute From: aquahaute Date: February 29th, 2012 01:52 am (UTC) (Link)
The necklace that's for sale in Borgin and Burkes' in book two is the one that curses Katie Bell coming back from Hogsmeade in book six.

Now I think of it, the Hand of Glory and OF COURSE how I did I not think of this earlier - the vanishing cabinet! They're ALL in Borgin and Burkes' when Harry eavesdrops on the Malfoys after he winds up accidentally in Knockturn Alley - he actually hides in the cabinet then, but doesn't close the door all the way. The Hand of Glory is only a minor point in book six, but the vanishing cabinets come up over and over again in several books before going RELEVANT LIEK WOAH in book six.
kagami From: kagami Date: August 4th, 2009 08:48 am (UTC) (Link)
The worst is Order of the Phoenix, as far as I'm concerned. Although, the book wasn't so bad compared to the movie. I couldn't believe how bored I was during that.
ardweden From: ardweden Date: August 5th, 2009 01:13 am (UTC) (Link)
I liked the Order of the Phoenix movie. Thought they did that one really well.

Couldn't stand movie 4, though. That's what, Goblet of Fire. UGH.
dreol From: dreol Date: August 5th, 2009 01:26 am (UTC) (Link)
I actually quite like Book 5. But I think that's because my favorite characters are Lupin and Sirius and they played some major roles. Of course it was also a really devastating book to me for the same reason. My favorite book, I think, is still book 3 which I'm re-reading now. But yes the 4th movie is very confusing if you haven't read the book, and I also liked movie 5 quite a lot, though they did change it a great deal.
capfox From: capfox Date: August 6th, 2009 03:38 pm (UTC) (Link)
I agree with Brett; the worst was book 5, which felt a bit angry and sulky and in need of editing. I'm not a huge fan of the second book, as these things go, but it's certainly not bad.
10 penguins saved | Harpoon a whale